Commotion in SBE faculty council student fraction about the grade for participation in tutorial groups

Commotion in SBE faculty council student fraction about the grade for participation in tutorial groups

What do you have to do to pass 'participation'?

01-11-2022 · News

MAASTRICHT. Faculty council student members of the School of Business and Economics (SBE) are worried about the grade they will receive for ‘participation’ in the tutorial group meetings. At the moment, it is unclear what the demands are, they said during the latest faculty council meeting. The students want clear regulations.

For many subjects, attendance alone is not enough. SBE expects an active attitude. For some courses, students receive a grade for their participation; it usually counts partially towards the final grade. Sometimes, there is a pass/fail system and students who receive a fail have to do an extra assignment.

So, a good grade for this item is important, the students emphasise. But what you have to do to pass, is unclear, they added. “I received an e-mail from my tutor that as things stand, I won’t pass,” says student council member Ellemijn Egberink. Strange, she feels, because she “says something three times per half hour”. Her tutor advised her to say more, “but that is impossible because the tutorial group meetings for this subject are always short. We go through the questions very quickly, sometimes it doesn’t last longer than half an hour.” Whether the content of the remarks during the meetings plays a role, was not clear.

Even after a talk with her tutor, Egberink doesn’t know how she can boost her grade. Could there not be clear rules for this item, Egberink wanted to know from the faculty board.

Dean Mariëlle Heiltjes is not an advocate of more regulations. “There is a joint responsibility to agree on this at the beginning of the block.” The dean feels that tutors have to explain what they expect and the other way around, students have to ask questions when that explanation is not given. 

Author: Yuri Meesen

Photo: Observant

Tags: Participation,SBE,F-council

Responses

Caroline Kortbeek

One sentence in the article worries me: “but that is impossible because the tutorial group meetings for this subject are always short. We go through the questions very quickly, sometimes it doesn’t last longer than half an hour.”
Tutorials are scheduled for 2 hours. Not all will last the entire 2 hours, sometimes there is a break halfway, but students should be able to participate in discussions - the core of our PBL . If the sessions are much shorter and if only questions are addresses, that is not how the UM sees our eduation format (and participation and input cannot properly be assessed).

Add Response

Click here for our privacy statement.

Since January 2022, Observant only publishes comments of people whose name is known to the editors.