A new era for fossil hunting in Maastricht: “You could be standing right on top of a mosasaur”

First-ever UM research in ENCI quarry

25-09-2024 · Science

The fossil discoveries at the Sint-Pietersberg, particularly those of mosasaurs, are renowned throughout the world. For many years, Maastricht University wasn’t involved in palaeontological fieldwork at the site. But this is now changing as a new era of research dawns. “We no longer have diggers breathing down our necks.”

Say the word “Maastricht” to a geologist or palaeontologist, and their eyes will likely light up. This is certainly true for Leon Claessens, professor of Vertebrate Palaeontology and Evolution at UM since 2019. After enjoying his time in the United States, conducting research at prestigious universities like Harvard, he couldn’t resist the opportunity to return to the region where he grew up. “Maastricht is world-famous in my field.”

Open any textbook and you’ll see that the period from roughly 72 to 66 million years ago – the last age of the Cretaceous period – is called the Maastrichtian. And this isn’t a mere footnote in Earth’s history, Claessens explains. “It ended with the meteor that wiped out the dinosaurs – an iconic event everyone knows about, from scientists to young children.”

Maastricht owes this distinction to the typical limestone (locally referred to as mergel, marl) deposited in this age in the substrata of Sint-Pietersberg (Mount Saint Peter hill). At the time, what is now South Limburg was a shallow subtropical sea, “similar to the Bahamas”, with a rich marine ecosystem. As a result, the ground is replete with fossils.

Revolutionary idea

One of the most significant finds is the mosasaur, a giant marine predator that ruled the seas during the Maastrichtian. In the 18th century, the first fossils of this species were discovered in the underground tunnel system in the hill. Especially the discovery of a nearly intact skull in 1778 (see box) drew a lot of attention. Scientists puzzled over the identity of “Le Grand Animal de Maestricht”. Was it a whale? An oversized crocodile?

Eventually, in 1808, naturalist Georges Cuvier concluded that the creature was a previously unknown extinct species. This was a revolutionary idea: the concept of extinction was virtually unknown at the time. “It was largely through the mosasaur that extinction was ‘discovered’”, says Claessens. As a nod to the find near the Meuse River, the sea creature was later named “mosasaur”, “Meuse lizard”. It put Maastricht on the scientific map – a position that was cemented in 1849, when the Belgian geologist André Dumont introduced the name “the Maastrichtian” for the period when mosasaurs thrived.

Time pressure

Two centuries later, the fascination endures stronger than ever. Earlier this month, a conference marking the 175th anniversary of the Maastrichtian drew dozens of scientists from all over the world to the city. “And after that, Maastricht hosted the triennial Mosasaur Meeting for the first time since 2004, with about fifty participants”, says Claessens. “It’s more than just dusty old facts. There’s still a lot of research being done on the period.”

This research includes fieldwork at the ENCI quarry. Over the past century, limestone mining for cement production uncovered several rare fossils of mosasaurs and other exotic creatures. The ENCI company’s industrial activity at the site was a blessing in a way, says Claessens. “Without it, these fossils would probably never have been found. But it was frustrating at the same time. Researchers were always working under immense time pressure. The ENCI diggers were always breathing down their necks. After all, time is money. And yes, there’s a good chance that a number of mosasaurs were ground into cement.”

Sea turtles

Since ENCI stopped limestone mining in 2018, a “new era” of research has begun, says Claessens. “We can finally conduct research without pressure, with the full cooperation of the new quarry owner, [nature conservation organisation] Natuurmonumenten.” This has opened up new avenues of research. “Instead of rushing to find the best fossils, we can take the time to understand the whole context. What was the ecosystem like at the time of the mosasaurs? How did it evolve over millennia? Which animal and plant species appeared and disappeared due to migration or extinction, for example?”

A new multi-year study aims to answer these questions. This summer, researchers and students of the Maastricht Science Programme (MSP), along with volunteers, conducted the first fieldwork at the ENCI quarry. “This is UM’s first proper palaeontological research at the site”, says Claessens. “It’s very exciting because of the rich diversity of fossils – squids, sharks, sea turtles, oysters, sea urchins, and even plankton and microfossils.”

Surprising discoveries

Wall of 'stairs' in the ENCI-quarry: the location of UM-fieldwork

The work takes place on an imposing wall of terraced steps, “almost like a Mayan temple”, carved out by ENCI specially for research. “With each few centimetres you dig, you go back thousands of years in time. This allows us to study ecosystem changes layer by layer.” The researchers use traditional palaeontological tools – chisels and brushes – but also a 3D scanner. “The scanner maps the top layer with millimetre precision. We do this for every layer we uncover. The end goal is a digital ‘book’ that lets you flip through time. It’s an unprecedented wealth of data.”

In the coming months, students will work on the fossil finds and 3D data. Fieldwork will resume next summer, as soon as the weather permits. “In a few years, we hope to have a clear picture of how the Maastrichtian ecosystems evolved.”

Despite the focus on the broader context, surprising discoveries are still possible. Claessens points to a bird fossil found in the quarry by amateur palaeontologists a few years ago. “It had an advanced jaw with teeth, which was previously thought to have evolved much later. The discovery overturned a century of consensus on bird evolution. And the great thing is, the next unknown species or mosasaur skull could be just a few centimetres beneath your feet. You’re never done exploring here.”
 

Back to Maastricht?

The mosasaur skull discovered in 1778 thrust Maastricht into the scientific limelight, but it didn’t remain in the city for long. In 1795, French troops took the fossil to Paris as a trophée de guerre, a war trophy. Since then, it’s been one of the highlights of the Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle. But that could soon change if the Maastricht city council has its way. Last year, the council approved a motion requesting that the municipality, possibly in collaboration with the national government, initiate talks with France about its return.

Is this mission feasible? “Getting it back permanently will be very difficult”, says Donna Yates, associate professor in the department of Criminal Law and Criminology who studies fossil trade. “There are no legal instruments to enforce it. Taking spoils of war wasn’t illegal at the time. Moreover, French law makes it very difficult to give up ‘state property’.”

Mosasaur fossil in the Natural History Museum of Maastricht. Photo: NHM Maastricht

According to Yates, dialogue is the only option. “But France isn’t known for returning looted treasures. There would need to be a good reason. Colonial guilt isn’t relevant here. Additionally, the scientific and cultural context of the fossil is largely French – most of the research has been done there.” But nothing ventured, nothing gained. “Talks could pave the way for a mutually beneficial collaboration between research institutions. The mosasaur could come here for temporary exhibitions [as occurred before in 2009], and there could be exchanges of students and researchers, as well as other museum objects.”

In the meantime, there’s still a way to admire mosasaur fossils in Maastricht. The Natural History Museum of Maastricht has several more recently discovered specimens on display, along with an eleven-metre-long reconstructed skeleton of the sea creature unveiled just last month.

Photos: Observant

Tags: mosasaur,maastrichtian,fossils,enci-quarry,sint-pietersberg,msp,fse,geology,paleontology,research,instagram

Add Response

Click here for our privacy statement.

Since January 2022, Observant only publishes comments of people whose name is known to the editors.